GTA 6 Guides

Should You Kill or Spare Arnold in GTA 6? Hey Arnold! Choice Explained

Arnold on his knees at the end of a jetty while Jason decides

Hey Arnold! gives you one of the first real choices in GTA 6. Here is what happens and why most guides say let him go

GTA 6 GuidesLast Updated: By: BoostBase GTA 6 Team3 min read

Kill or Spare Arnold? Quick Overview:

  • Spare him
  • Arnold is Brian’s broker, and at the end of the Chapter 1 mission Hey Arnold! Jason corners him on a jetty and Brian wants him dead
  • Killing him pushes Jason’s criminal profile toward Hardened, and letting him go keeps it clean, while the story carries on the same way either way
  • One guide says sparing him also leads to a small extra moment with Brian later

Who is Arnold in GTA 6?

Arnold is a long time business contact of Brian Heder who stops answering Brian’s calls after the trouble with the Kingfishers. Guides call him Brian’s broker or associate. Brian thinks he has turned on him, so he takes Jason to find him

Brian and Jason by the water before the chase
Brian takes Jason to find Arnold

Hey Arnold! mission walkthrough

Jason chasing Arnold down a jetty past a moored yacht
Arnold runs to the end of the jetty
Map of GTA 6 showing Crastenburg HotelOn the mapCrastenburg Hotel
Crastenburg Hotel · Key Lento, where Brian waits at the start of Hey Arnold!
  1. Meet Brian at the Crastenburg Hotel. Hey Arnold! is the eighth mission of Chapter 1, right after Just a Scratch. Arnold was meant to meet you there and is gone
  2. Track him down and chase him on foot. Arnold runs as soon as he sees you. Keep up with him until he runs out of room
  3. Corner him on the jetty. Brian tells Jason to shut him up for good
  4. Make the choice. Shoot him, or let him go. If you wait too long, Arnold jumps in the water and swims off, which counts as sparing him
PRO tipOnce Arnold is in the water you cannot shoot him, so take your time if you want to spare him

Should you kill or spare Arnold?

ChoiceCriminal profileLater
KillPushes Jason toward HardenedStory carries on the same
SpareKeeps Jason cleanOne guide says a small extra moment with Brian later

Guides agree the choice does not change the main story. Whatever you pick, Jason tells Brian that Arnold will keep quiet, and Brian then introduces Kenton, which opens Island Dreams. Where guides differ is the profile. One says killing gives a Hardened rating and sparing a Restrained one. In game, Restrained is a tag that pops up next to an action, not a profile level, and the others do not name a rating. Our criminal profile guide explains why needless kills matter

Arnold swimming away from the jetty
Wait and Arnold swims off, which counts as sparing him

Does killing Arnold affect the ending?

Not on its own. No guide has tied this choice to the ending, but it adds to your criminal profile, and one guide says the profile plays a part at the end. Our endings guide covers what does matter

Coming soon · PS5 and Xbox

Story Completion

Any chapter or the full story · Prologue to the campaign finale · Side stories on request

Starts at$15

Frequently asked questions

Should you kill Arnold in GTA 6?

Most guides say spare him. Killing him only hurts your criminal profile

What happens if you spare Arnold?

He swims away, and one guide says you get a small extra moment with Brian later

Which mission is Arnold in?

Hey Arnold!, the eighth mission of Chapter 1

Does the Arnold choice change the story?

No, the next scenes are the same either way

Who is Arnold in GTA 6?

Brian Heder’s broker, who stops answering after the Kingfishers trouble

GTA 6 came out on November 19, 2026, and the guide sites are still checking it against the game, so every number here was compared across at least two sources and the majority wins where they disagree

Did you like the article?

Rate it!

You may also like

All 133 GTA 6 guides ›