GTA 6 asks you to decide more often than any GTA before it. Here is what each choice really does
GTA 6 Choices and Consequences Quick Overview:
- Most GTA 6 choices change your Criminal Profile, your relationship with Lucia or a cash reward, not the story
- The best known is Hey Arnold! in Chapter 1, where sparing Arnold keeps Jason Restrained
- Killing Felipe pays $20,000, the Halifax statue opens a long side chain, and only the last choices before the finale decide your ending
Do choices matter in GTA 6?
Some do. One choices guide lists 27 decision points, and most change dialogue, your Criminal Profile or your relationship with Lucia. A few lock or open side content and cash. Only the last choices before the finale pick your ending. Guides agree on what most choices do, but they split on some later payoffs, which we flag below

Should you kill or spare Arnold in GTA 6?
On the mapCrastenburg HotelSpare him. In Hey Arnold!, the eighth mission of Chapter 1, Arnold kneels on the pier and you choose. Killing him adds a Hardened mark to Jason’s profile. Sparing him counts as Restrained, and he jumps into the sea and swims away. Most guides say there is no reward either way. One says a spared Arnold comes back in Chapter 4 with a $10,000 thank-you from Brian, and another says a later moment with Brian happens, but others report nothing, so do not count on the money. Our Arnold guide has the full mission
Every GTA 6 choice and its consequence
Chapter 1 and 2 choices, tap to show
| Mission | Choice | What changes |
|---|---|---|
| Steal the Scooter | Take Peggy’s scooter or refuse | Taking it unlocks Shirley’s Penumbra with paw print decals |
| Buck Me! | Say Nothing or Saved Cash | Nothing, both play out the same |
| Day Release | Mention Brian’s retirement or stay quiet | Talking raises Lucia’s relationship |
| What’s In the Bag | Hand over the necklace or wait | Rent is covered either way |
Chapter 3 and 4 choices, tap to show
| Mission | Choice | What changes |
|---|---|---|
| Communication towers prep | Ask Lucia for help or go solo | Help clears all 3 towers and raises the relationship |
| The product sale | Sell pure or cut | Pure boosts your Professional rating, cut starts a price fight |
| Felipe | Kill or spare | Kill pays $20,000 to BuckMe, spare gets you his Declasse Impaler later |
| Halifax statue | Give it or refuse | Giving it opens a long chain with a Vapid 32 Hustler at the end |
| Kirk and the Skunk Ape | Wait for it to wake, then shoot | Pays $10,000 to BuckMe |
| Gene on the roadside | Cover for him | Gives you a Luxury Watch collectible |
| Gym infiltration | Take the steroids | Lucia can reach a 5 of 5 body rating |
| Shayna’s boyfriend | He’s Not Worth It or He Deserves It | Decides whether she shoots him |
Most rows come from one full choices guide. The Felipe, statue and Arnold payoffs are the ones players argue about most, so check them against your own game before you plan around them

Which choices change the ending?
Only the choices in the finale. Before the last mission the game asks if you are ready, and after an ending it puts you back at that moment so you can choose again. Our endings guide explains each outcome

The final choice, tap to show
On the bridge you choose how Jason and Lucia try to get away. One guide says Swim For It without a gun lets Lucia escape while Jason is arrested, and No Surrender ends with both of them dying. The armed version of Swim For It is still unconfirmed

Story Completion
Any chapter or the full story · Prologue to the campaign finale · Side stories on request
Frequently asked questions
Do choices matter in GTA 6?
Some do. Most change your profile, Lucia or cash, and only the finale picks the ending
Should I kill or spare Arnold in GTA 6?
Spare him. It keeps Jason Restrained and there is no reward for killing him
What happens if you spare Arnold in GTA 6?
He swims away. One guide says Brian pays $10,000 for it in Chapter 4, others found nothing
Should you kill Felipe in GTA 6?
Killing him pays $20,000. Sparing him gets you his Declasse Impaler later
Can you change your choices in GTA 6?
Only by loading an older save. The finale is the one choice you can replay
GTA 6 came out on November 19, 2026, and the guide sites are still checking it against the game, so every number here was compared across at least two sources and the majority wins where they disagree

